See What Children Know
Click on the thumbnail to watch this video inside our video library. Listen to the child’s explanation of his map. His uses his map as a hybrid of storyboard and spatial notation. For example, the three rocks on 8th Street become the protagonist in the child’s story. They serve as a spatial point of reference, a challenge for breaking through them, an obstacle to hurdle to get across the empty space on the map to the closest street mark, and something that is known only to people who have actually been “on” 8th Street.
Of particular interest is the child’s understanding of shared perspective. One would not know of the three rocks on 8th Street unless one had actually been on Spruce Street (which in reality is a cross street to 8th in Boulder where he lives). He also makes a distinction between information that is deliberately withheld (a secret) and information that is simply unfamiliar (lack of experience). To the teacher’s question about the rocks, “Is it a secret?” the child replies, “No, but you just don’t know because you have never been to Spruce Street.”
We can confidently conclude that the child’s marks represent the spatial layout of real objects drawn to instruct one to know how to get around. The marks do more than represent how a generic object looks, such as drawing a generalized house or even a conventional playground. The child drew his map with the intent to help someone navigate passage from the rocks to his house, (e.g. “There’s a path through the rocks.”). It is true that his marks are curves and not the Euclidean (straight lines and angles) grid of the Boulder streets. Nevertheless, the marks are meant to be read as paths that instruct one on what direction to move. The marks have a procedural intent and not simply a pictorial or declarative intent. The fact that they are curves does not destroy the power of his symbols to capture what is connected and what is not connected. These topological attributes of connection and continuity are often understood as a stage earlier than the Euclidean attributes of straight lines and angles. The quantitative attributes of length and proportion of lines will come later. You see a budding interest in length when the child says, “Spruce Street is very little. Spruce Street is only this long. ” From these qualitative concepts, quantitative concepts of scale and measured length grow.
Click here to download a full transcript plus extended analysis of this video.
Click here to purchase a high resolution video file of Map Making as Story and Instruction plus extended analysis and a full transcript.
To subscribe to our streaming video library of over 225 video clips with supporting text, click here.
